Hier die Ergebnisse im direkten Vergleich von Level 25 und Apex Duel:
Level 25 und Apex Duel endeten mit der exakt gleichen Punktzahl.
Die Kombination beider Daten ergibt folgende Turnierstatistik:
Code:
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 SenseRobot AI : 3838 47 38 76 67.1 % 3714 65.8 %
2 Stockfish 18 : 3823 46 39 76 65.1 % 3715 67.1 %
3 Stockfish 17.1 : 3809 42 33 76 63.2 % 3715 73.7 %
4 Obsidian160 : 3791 40 33 76 60.5 % 3716 76.3 %
5 Clover.9.1 : 3768 40 37 76 57.2 % 3717 75.0 %
6 Berserk-13 : 3759 36 32 76 55.9 % 3718 80.3 %
7 Reckless 0.8.0 : 3759 36 32 76 55.9 % 3718 80.3 %
8 Alexandria-8.1.12 : 3755 37 34 76 55.3 % 3718 78.9 %
9 PlentyChess-7.0.0 : 3755 37 34 76 55.3 % 3718 78.9 %
10 Viridithas-19.0.1 : 3751 42 40 76 54.6 % 3718 72.4 %
11 Dragon 3.3 : 3746 37 34 76 53.9 % 3719 78.9 %
12 Pawnocchio-1.9.2 : 3746 41 39 76 53.9 % 3719 73.7 %
13 Caissa-1.24 : 3729 42 42 76 51.3 % 3720 71.1 %
14 Quanticade Cronus 3.0 : 3724 41 41 76 50.7 % 3720 72.4 %
15 Integral 7.0.0 : 3720 49 49 76 50.0 % 3720 60.5 %
16 Chess-System-Tal-2.00 : 3640 47 50 76 38.2 % 3724 60.5 %
17 Rebel-16.3 : 3607 53 56 76 33.6 % 3726 51.3 %
18 Rebel-EAS-3.0 : 3592 51 55 76 31.6 % 3727 52.6 %
19 Wasp 7.14 : 3539 58 62 76 25.0 % 3730 42.1 %
20 lc0-v0.32.1 : 3508 54 62 76 21.7 % 3731 43.4 %
Games : 760 (finished)
White Wins : 180 (23.7 %)
Black Wins : 65 ( 8.6 %)
Draws : 515 (67.8 %)
Unfinished : 0
White Perf. : 57.6 %
Black Perf. : 42.4 %
ECO A = 23 Games ( 3.0 %)
ECO B = 292 Games (38.4 %)
ECO C = 91 Games (12.0 %)
ECO D = 101 Games (13.3 %)
ECO E = 253 Games (33.3 %)
Hier ist eine Referenz-ELO-Wertung für alle durchgeführten Tests:
Code:
Reference Comparison SSDF CCRL CCRL N/A N/A
~~~~~SenseRobot AI Rating~~~~~ ~40 Moves/120 Sec~ ~40 Moves/15 Min~ ~120 Sec+1 Sec~ ~ 3 Sec/Move~ ~1Sec/Move~
Level 22 (2300 ELO) 2945 3138 - - -
Level 23 (2500 ELO) 3200 3393 - - -
Level 24 (2700 ELO) 3407 3548 - - -
Level 25 (2900 ELO) 3477 3623 3760 3790 3837
Apex Duel (3200 ELO) 3477 3605 3795 3780 3837
Level 25 + Apex Duel Combined 3477 3614 3778 3785 3837
Ich habe auch das Buch noch einmal verglichen:
SenseRobot AI und Stockfish 18 spielen Weiß
Code:
White~ Black~ Move #~ Evals~ Devi#~ Dval~ Result~ ~~~~~ White~ Black~ Move #~ Evals~ Result~
Sense SF18 11B -0.40 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Tal2 11B -0.29 Lost
Sense Alex 11B -0.17 #6 -0.13 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Plen 11B -0.16 Draw
Sense Quan 11B -0.44 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Reas 11B -0.14 Draw
Sense Bers 11B -0.13 #8 -0.28 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Quan 11B -0.32 Draw
Sense Obsi 11B -0.07 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Drag 11B -0.39 Lost
Sense R16 11B -0.51 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Pawn 11B -0.27 Lost
Sense Tal2 11B -0.70 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Reck 11B 0.06 Draw
Sense Cais 11B -0.30 #7 -0.35 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Alex 11B -0.66 Draw
Sense Clov 11B -0.33 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 R16 11B -0.86 Lost
Sense LC0 11B -0.28 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 SF17 11B -0.69 Draw
Sense Viri 11B -0.25 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Wasp 11B -0.13 Lost
Sense SF17 11B -0.13 #9 -0.19 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Bers 11B -0.57 Draw
Sense Reas 11B -0.69 #6 -0.58 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Inte 11B -0.31 Lost
Sense Wasp 11B -0.59 #10 -0.72 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Cais 11B -0.42 Lost
Sense Drag 11B -0.30 #9 -0.22 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Viri 11B -0.28 Lost
Sense Pawn 11B -0.26 #7 -0.05 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 LC0 11B -0.50 Lost
Sense Inte 11B -0.16 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Obsi 11B -0.26 Draw
Sense Plen 11B 0.13 #9 0.22 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Sense 11B -0.14 Draw
Sense Reck 11B 0.00 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Clov 11B -0.26 Draw
~~~~~ ~~~~~ AV -0.29 AV -0.26 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ AV -0.35 ~~~~~
~~~~~ ~~~~~ LO -0.41 LO -0.37 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ LO -0.38 ~~~~~
~~~~~ ~~~~~ DR -0.19 DR -0.11 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ DR -0.31 ~~~~~
SenseRobot AI und Stockfish 18 spielen Schwarz
Code:
Black~ White~ Move #~ Evals~ Devi#~ Dval~ Result~ ~~~~~ Black~ White~ Move #~ Evals~ Result~
Sense LC0 11W 0.27 #8 0.33 Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Pawn 11W 0.29 Draw
Sense Drag 11W 0.69 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Drag 11W 0.28 Draw
Sense Viri 11W 0.12 #7 0.06 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Viri 11W 0.40 Draw
Sense SF18 11W 0.14 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Obsi 11W 0.01 Draw
Sense SF17 11W 0.44 #8 0.48 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Inte 11W 0.18 Draw
Sense Wasp 11W 0.63 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Reck 11W 0.19 Draw
Sense Bers 11W 0.42 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Wasp 11W 0.51 Draw
Sense Alex 11W 0.20 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Tal2 11W 0.00 Draw
Sense Pawn 11W 0.78 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Sense 11W 0.40 Draw
Sense Inte 11W 0.71 #9 0.80 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Quan 11W 0.45 Draw
Sense Quan 11W 0.66 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Reas 11W 0.27 Lost
Sense Reck 11W 0.41 #8 0.52 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 SF17 11W 0.56 Draw
Sense R16 11W 0.72 #8 0.68 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Plen 11W 0.13 Draw
Sense Tal2 11W 0.63 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Alex 11W 0.30 Draw
Sense Obsi 11W 0.09 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 LC0 11W -0.01 Lost
Sense Plen 11W 0.27 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Bers 11W 0.00 Draw
Sense Reas 11W -0.01 - - Lost ~~~~~ SF18 Cais 11W 0.26 Draw
Sense Cais 11W 0.75 - - Draw ~~~~~ SF18 Clov 11W 0.10 Draw
Sense Clov 11W 0.75 #7 0.82 Draw ~~~~~ SF18 R16 11W 0.52 Draw
~~~~~ ~~~~~ AV 0.46 AV 0.53 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ AV 0.25 ~~~~~
~~~~~ ~~~~~ LO 0.29 LO 0.33 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ LO 0.13 ~~~~~
~~~~~ ~~~~~ DR 0.50 DR 0.56 ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~~~~~ DR 0.27 ~~~~~
Auch diesmal zeigten sich durch die Verwendung unterschiedlicher Eröffnungsbücher keine erkennbaren Vorteile.
Falls es jemanden interessiert, hier sind die Spiele in einer PGN-Datei zusammengefasst:
https://www.schachcomputer.info/foru...1&d=1772819902
Damit sind alle Servertests abgeschlossen.
Viele Gruesse
Nick